19.7 C
Friday, September 29, 2023
    HomeNewsAmericaAmerica’s Arab and Muslim leaders failing to produce change

    America’s Arab and Muslim leaders failing to produce change

    - Advertisement -


    August 31, 2022 arabnews.com

    America’s Arab and Muslim leaders failing to produce change
    Rep. Rashida Tlaib (L) at a campaign rally on July 29, 2022 in Pontiac, Michigan. (Getty Images/AFP)

    Short Url

    Arab and Muslim Americans tend to live in a fantasy land of their own creation, especially when it comes to US politics. They do not want to hear about it and they do not want to do anything about it.

    For example, Arabs and Muslims are willing to accept the rhetoric of President Joe Biden and Rep. Rashida Tlaib, the so-called leader of the Arab American community. But they do not care that their rhetoric is infertile and produces no actual results.

    Biden says all the right things when it comes to the majority of Arab Americans. During his election campaign, Biden promised to address the community’s issues and to offer jobs to its members, ensuring that Arab and Muslim Americans would be a part of his administration. He also vowed to reverse some of the policies that his predecessor Donald Trump imposed, such as banning the citizens of many Muslim-majority states from entering the US. Many Arabs and Muslims cheered when Biden defeated Trump.

    Trump started his presidency hoping to work with Arabs but was quickly attacked and vilified by Arabs in Congress, who put their partisan politics above the best interests of the community. Arab and Muslim Americans quickly attacked Trump, exaggerating his efforts to stop extremists from the Middle East from entering the country.

    The reality often conflicted with the political goals of some Arab leaders, particularly Tlaib, who used profanity to pander to the emotions of the Arab American community. Tlaib does a great job of wearing Arab ethnic clothing, speaking out against injustice — when it comes from people she doesn’t like — and introducing legislation that fails to produce any results, other than making big headlines in the feeble Arab American news media.

    Instead of fighting for effective results, like convincing 218 members of the House of Representatives (50 percent plus one) to support issues of justice, Tlaib and some of her supporters prefer to champion losing battles, such as introducing the Nakba resolution, which had a total of six co-sponsors. This high-sounding resolution will never get a hearing or enough votes to make a real statement.

    That is our problem as Arab Americans. We tend to prefer emotion over achievement. Better to scream for justice, because it is easy, than to fight for justice, which is difficult and requires more strategic consensus-building. It is why many Arab Americans and Muslims are hesitant to openly criticize Biden, whose rhetoric and actions on Arab American and Muslim concerns are often in conflict.

    As long as Tlaib says what we want to hear, why press her for more?

    Ray Hanania

    It does not help for Biden to appoint two dozen Arabs and Muslims to his administration and only put them in secondary roles. Or for him to restrict their public participation to prevent them from saying anything that might offend Israel.

    In fact, while Biden promised to support their issues, apparently he was not talking about their concerns in the Middle East. The killing of Shireen Abu Akleh, the American Palestinian journalist shot dead by an Israeli sniper on May 10 in Jenin, is going the way of most injustices against Arabs — fading into the sunset unresolved and without ever seeing justice.

    How is it possible for Congress to fail to speak out when an American citizen is murdered in cold blood? When it involves Israel’s military, which thrives on billions of dollars each year in American taxpayer funding, it is challenging. But Abu Akleh was an American citizen. She was killed, yet nothing. Her name is fading out of the headlines and into Arab and Muslim anger and emotion.

    Tlaib may seem like a great voice for Arab and Muslim concerns, but she is not being held accountable for her actions. As long as she says what we want to hear, why press her for more?

    For example, why doesn’t the Arab and Muslim community, with leadership from Tlaib, force U-turns from the 26 American states that have illegally adopted laws that undermine the fundamental free speech principles of the US Constitution by passing anti-Boycott Divestment and Sanctions laws?

    The anti-BDS laws basically say that any American citizen who supports a boycott of Israel’s illegal and racist settler movement can be denied contracts and employment from the state because of that opinion. Their opponents contend that the laws are states’ rights issues and not federal, so they cannot do anything about them. But the reality is they do not want to because it requires too much work. Rhetoric, meanwhile, does not require much effort.

    In reality, the anti-BDS laws are a federal issue because they violate the US Constitution. Arab American leaders should set aside their rhetoric and use politics to persuade 218 members of Congress to vote to prohibit states from denying Americans their constitutional right to free speech. But that would mean them having to step back from their policies of political polarization and instead find a consensus.

     Ray Hanania is an award-winning former Chicago City Hall political reporter and columnist. He can be reached on his personal website at http://www.Hanania.com.
    Twitter: @RayHanania

    Disclaimer: Views expressed by writers in this section are their own and do not necessarily reflect Arab News’ point of view

    source https://www.arabnews.com/node/2154091


    Please enter your comment!
    Please enter your name here

    Keep exploring...

    Complete Guide to Eid Prayer: Rituals, Cleanliness, Process, and More

    Eid Prayer is a significant festival in Islam, marking the end of Ramadan, the holy month of fasting. One of the most important aspects...

    Eid Al-Fitr: A Comprehensive Guide to Recommended Acts on the Day of Celebration

    Eid Al-Fitr, often referred to as "Eid," is one of the most significant and joyous festivals in the Islamic calendar. It marks the end...

    Related Stories

    Uttar Pradesh Teacher Arrested for Alleged Communal Incident in Classroom

    In a recent development, the Uttar Pradesh Police apprehended a schoolteacher on Thursday for...

    Inspiring Journey: Guinean Student’s Epic Bike Ride to Secure a Spot at a Top Islamic University

    In a remarkable display of determination, Mamadou Safaiou Barry, a young Guinean student, embarked...

    12th Islamic World Ministers of Culture Conference Endorses Doha Declaration to Revitalize Cultural Endeavors

    Under the distinguished patronage of His Highness the Amir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad al-Thani,...

    Agong Urges Muslims to Embrace Prophet Muhammad’s Virtues on Maulidur Rasul

    In a heartfelt address on Maulidur Rasul, Yang di-Pertuan Agong Al-Sultan Abdullah Ri’ayatuddin Al-Mustafa...

    Assessing Nehru’s Impact on the Plight of Indian Muslims

    Pratinav Anil's latest literary endeavor, "Another India: The Making of the World's Largest Muslim...

    President Wickremesinghe Encourages Unity Among Muslims to Address National Challenges

    In a special address commemorating Milad-un-Nabi, President Ranil Wickremesinghe has called upon the Muslim...

    Iran Expresses Outrage Over Holy Qur’an Desecration in Netherlands

    In an official statement released on Thursday, the spokesperson for Iran's Ministry of Foreign...

    India’s Treatment of Muslims: A Concerning Pattern of Alienation

    In his inaugural address to the United Nations General Assembly, Caretaker Prime Minister Anwarul...

    Explore More Articles

    Welcome to the enlightening realm of our Islamic Articles Page – a digital sanctuary where knowledge, spirituality, and the rich tapestry of Islamic culture converge. In an era where information flows ceaselessly and the world seems to spin faster each day, our platform stands as a steadfast beacon of wisdom and reflection.