A Changing Sense of Security
Since the UAE formalized relations with Israel under the Abraham Accords in 2020, Israelis have perceived the Gulf nation as a secure and welcoming destination. However, the recent killing of Rabbi Zvi Kogan in Abu Dhabi has shaken this confidence and presented a diplomatic and domestic challenge for the UAE’s leadership.
Rabbi Zvi Kogan, a dual citizen of Israel and Moldova, was a prominent figure in the UAE’s Jewish community. Serving as a Chabad emissary and managing a kosher grocery store in Dubai, Kogan and his family had been living in the UAE since 2022. His disappearance on November 21 and the discovery of his body three days later in Al Ain, near the Omani border, have raised significant concerns.
The UAE authorities quickly apprehended three Uzbek nationals suspected of the crime, with the suspects being extradited from Turkey following an international manhunt. The swift response underscores the UAE’s commitment to addressing this incident but also points to the complexities of maintaining its image as a haven of tolerance and safety.
A Blow to the UAE’s Reputation
The killing of Kogan has prompted strong condemnations from Israel, Moldova, and the UAE. Emirati Ambassador to the U.S., Yousef al-Otaiba, emphasized the gravity of the incident, labeling it an assault on the UAE’s core values and national image.
The UAE has long prided itself on being a bastion of coexistence, promoting a multicultural society where residents and visitors from various backgrounds live harmoniously. This incident, however, threatens to expose vulnerabilities in the country’s carefully cultivated reputation.
READ MORE: Sambhal Mosque Survey: Police Deploy Tear Gas to Disperse Protesters During Clashes
Dr. Monica Marks, a Middle East politics expert, noted that the UAE’s emphasis on tolerance and safety is not merely idealistic but central to its diplomatic and economic strategies. “For the UAE, this image is integral to its vision of stability and prosperity, attracting global residents, tourists, and investors,” she explained.
A Regional and Diplomatic Quagmire
The murder has not only stirred fears within the Jewish community in the UAE but also invited speculation about broader motivations. Some experts suggest that the act was aimed at tarnishing the UAE’s global standing rather than targeting Israel directly.
Dr. Mira al-Hussein, an Emirati sociologist, argued that the crime might have been a calculated effort to challenge the UAE’s celebrated security apparatus and undermine its image of coexistence. She pointed out that the attackers likely sought to amplify the incident’s media impact, exploiting the symbolic nature of Kogan’s role in the Jewish community.
Moreover, while some analysts have speculated about potential anti-Israeli motives, others, like Dr. Hussein Ibish from the Arab Gulf States Institute, highlighted the broader geopolitical context. The murder could resonate with anti-Israeli and anti-Jewish sentiments fueled by regional tensions, particularly amid the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Managing the Fallout
The UAE’s response to this incident has been closely scrutinized. Initial reports of Kogan’s disappearance appeared in Israeli media, with official Emirati statements following hours later. The cautious wording of these statements, emphasizing Kogan’s Moldovan citizenship and omitting his religious role, suggests an effort to manage the narrative delicately.
Allegations of Iranian involvement have further complicated the situation. While Israeli officials have hinted at Tehran’s role in orchestrating the murder, no evidence has surfaced to substantiate these claims. The Iranian embassy in Abu Dhabi has categorically denied any connection, and the UAE appears cautious about allowing these accusations to derail its improving relations with Iran.
Former U.S. Ambassador Gordon Gray emphasized that linking Iran to the murder could strain UAE-Iran relations, a delicate balancing act for the Gulf nation. “Abu Dhabi must tread carefully to avoid escalating tensions while maintaining its sovereignty and security,” Gray observed.
Implications for Security and Stability
The UAE’s leadership is now focused on ensuring such incidents do not recur. Enhanced security measures, increased surveillance, and careful management of public messaging will likely be central to their strategy.
Dr. Marks noted that while fewer Israelis may visit the UAE in the short term, the long-term diplomatic and economic ties forged by the accords are unlikely to unravel.
The Road Ahead
As the UAE navigates the aftermath of Rabbi Kogan’s killing, its response will be critical in shaping perceptions both domestically and internationally. The incident serves as a reminder of the challenges inherent in balancing regional diplomacy, security, and the promotion of multicultural harmony.
Ultimately, the UAE’s ability to address this crisis decisively and transparently will be crucial in preserving its reputation as a beacon of tolerance and stability in a volatile region.
